How Metal is Archaeological Theory?

METALBINFORD

Let me begin by addressing the students of the Applied Archaeology program – don’t let anyone scare you out of Dr. Phil’s seminar. Because it rules. The class is theory-heavy, but the first day of class involved discussion of tall, tongue-rolling, Vulcans. Just sayin.

For my next trick, I will clarify some confusing archaeological typology terms using heavy metal music.

As I struggle once more through the fiery depths of archaeological theory in Dr. Phil’s seminar – the metal gods shine light upon dense articles by Brew, Steward and Setzler, McKern, Krieger, Willey and Phillips, Ford, Spaulding, and Binford. If you’ve been forced to familiarize yourself with these names before, grisly images of death and destruction may come to mind as well as the great typology debate – fought across peer-reviewed journal lines. A long winded battle, where “the screams of anguished authors who fear[ed] that their brain children [were] being murdered by reviewers” could be heard ringing through the notes and comments of American Antiquity and American Anthropologist in the early 1950s (Ford 1954).

As we stage dive into the history of typology in archaeology, and before you start banging your head against your desk – I know, theory can be brutal. But Willey and Phillips actually started to make sense to me after I applied the terminology to heavy metal typology.  And it offered some real life advice: define your freaking terminology, people. Clearly.

Maybe this is TMI, but this past week as I was wading through the OkCupid dating scene – the old typology debate popped back into my head. (Yup, this is how my brain works…) More specifically, the advice that Willey and Phillips so wordily conveyed about the importance of defining your freaking terminology. I had many-a-conversation with dungeon masters and metal-heads alike over what metal bands they prefer over others.

Now, I am the first one to admit – I suck at metal typology. Going into this – I had no idea where hair metal stopped and thrash metal began. And I figured out why this is so confusing. Nobody knows what the heck they are talking about. And when one person says ‘black metal’ the other person has a completely different idea of what that means. One man’s death-doom is another man’s stoner-metal. Not one of these people, including myself could define the attributes of any one sub-genre of heavy metal. This made for very confusing conversation.

So I looked to the nerds of Wikipedia – because only they would devote so much time to writing the specific attributes of heavy metal sub-genres. (Ian Christe, Robert Walser, Garry Sharpe-Young, and Paul Du Noyer are some folks who have written about the evolution of metal and other genres of music.)

This is what I came up with (CLICK TO ENLARGE!):

metal typology

The chart describes types of heavy metal, complete with the attributes that define those types, and a few examples of those types. For instance, thrash can be distinguished by overall aggression, fast percussive beats, low register guitar riffs, and overlaid shredding – think Slayer and Megadeth. (Hahahaha – ‘overlaid shredding’ is a great attribute!)

Willey and Phillips’ discussions from their book, Method and Theory in Archaeology use the term ‘archaeology units’ instead of the word ‘type’ in an effort to keep definitions clear (Willey and Phillips 1958). Some of these terms are still used today and with similar meaning. So lets look at this in terms of our ‘metal units’ laid out in the above chart. According to Willey and Phillips’ terminology, our metal units would be considered traditions. Traditions are found across time, with a persistent configuration of technology, where specific elements are continuous. Where some attributes are shared among the separate units, they contrast enough to be separate entities and some occur at slightly later periods in time than others. So the traditions of heavy metal from the chart include hair metal, thrash, power metal, death metal, black metal, doom, and stoner metal. Stemming from the tradition of thrash, death metal emerges. The tradition of death metal is exemplified by heavy distortion, low tuned guitars, minor keys, key and time changes, and deep growling vocals. (These attributes are hilarious.)

This distinction of metal music is in contrast with the concept of the horizon. Horizons spread across space rapidly and are temporally similar – meaning they appear only in a short period of time and then disappear. This could be better likened to dance crazes as Dr. Phil so eloquently described and then nimbly demonstrated by doing ‘The Freddy.’ Look it up. Other examples include such favorites as The Watusi, The Electric Slide, and The Macarena. Points to you if you know all three.

So there you have it – archaeological theory applied to metal typology. I think this means I win. Maybe next week we can discuss the phases and sub-phases of prog rock and fusion.

PS

Keep your eyes peeled for the new archaeology department T-shirts, designed by yours truly. I’ll be ordering those at some point in February. Also – if there is want for repeats of last years T-Shirt, let me know. I need to order at least 10 for a reprint.

Metal Munsells:

Dude’s hair from Iron Maiden album, Killers: 5Y 7/8

Blood from Cannibal Corpse album, Butchered at Birth: 10R 4/8

Background of Witchcraft album, The Alchemist: 5Y 8/2

 

References Cited

Ford, James A.

1954 ‘Letter, “Spaulding’s Review of Ford,” American Anthropologist 56:109-112.

Willey, Gordon R,  Philip Phillips

1958 Method and Theory in American Archaeology. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

 

This entry was posted in Musings.

67 comments to How Metal is Archaeological Theory?

  1. dani says:

    wwih this is good information thanks ya

  2. Jack says:

    Interesting article. I’d consider myself a metalhead. I’ve been one since I was in middle school. Just thought I’d clarify a few things, metalwise. Dragonforce incorporates some elements of Power Metal, like the fantasy based lyrics, but they are primarily Speed Metal, a sub division of New Wave of British Heavy Metal (NWOBHM), which you don’t have listed either. These bands include Iron Maiden and Judas Priest to name a few. Manowar, one of my all time favorites, is Classic Heavy Metal. The Scorpions are Hard Rock and Heavy Metal.

    Power Metal includes bands like Helloween (being one of the oldest), Avantasia, Gamma Ray, Iron Savior, Edguy, Hammerfall, Grave Digger, Running Wild, Blind Guardian and pretty much anything Kai Hansen has touched. More modern day bands include Sabaton, Dream Evil, and Gloryhammer.

    Not to mention this subgenre can be divided even further down to American and European Style. The only real difference between the two is American originated from NWOBHM and Traditional metal and European originated from NWOBHM and Speed Metal. Plus there are even more subgenres if you really want to get specific, like Symphonic Power Metal, which include bands like Gloryhammer, but that is a whole other discussion.

    Now you make the argument that nobody knows what they are talking about. Could it be because bands can be defined as numerous genres of metal? Take for instance the band Stormwarrior. I’d classify them as speed metal first, followed by power metal. They blast through their music at a break neck pace like speed metal, but they also have more uplifting and melodic lyrics like power metal, similar to Dragonforce discussed above. As mentioned before European Power Metal originates from Speed and NWOBHM, so in this instance it can be tricky defining which genre a band fits into. That is unless you’ve listened to all the bands from across genres (At least all the big names for a chosen genre). Then you can make a highly accurate educated guess where the band gets most of its influences and even how to classify them.

    There are more subgenres that you could have touched on, like Speed Metal, NWOBHM, Nu Metal, Groove Metal, Symphonic Metal, Traditional Metal and Industrial Metal to name a few. With the pic you provided, it’s evident you’ve got a long way to go before you understand metal music and how to define it. However I know that was not the point of the article. Just thought I’d point a few things out.

  3. dsf dsfds says:

    thanks for posting this article

  4. vignesh NAGA says:

    Very nice blogs!!! I have to learn a lot of information from this site…

  5. Cole Byrne says:

    Thanks for sharing this! I’m delighted with this information, where such important moments are captured. All the best!

  6. AI Courses in Bangalore says:

    What an incredible message this is. Truly one of the best posts I have ever seen in my life. Wow, keep it up.
    AI Courses in Bangalore

  7. robin smithsters says:

    Information on web is always fascinating. Let me point you to this page with more interesting stuff!

  8. robin smithsters says:

    Internet is full of awesome data and this page is an excellent example of that.

  9. robin smithsters says:

    Click on this article, an interesting read and a must know information for everyone.

  10. julius hamilton says:

    Thank you for sharing such information. It is deep and educative. We provide assignments help to students. Visit our website for more information

  11. Lucy Gray says:

    Keep sharing this loving blog I appreciated this so much infact in 2021

    Squid Game Jacket.

  12. Data Science Course in Delhi says:

    thanks for sharing this post.
    Data Science Course in Delhi

  13. Business Analytics Course in Bangalore says:

    I am sure it will help many people. Keep up the good work. It’s very compelling and I enjoyed browsing the entire blog.
    Business Analytics Course in Bangalore

  14. sarah winget says:

    awesome blogs, each and every. visit – assignment provider for best of writing services!!!!

  15. Alley John says:

    A cheap assignment help service is a platform where students can get rid of all their academic woes in no time. In MyAssignmenthelp.com, our charges are designed to keep our students in mind. https://myassignmenthelp.com/cheap-assignment-help.html

  16. Data Science Course in Noida says:

    thanks for sharing this post..
    Data Science Course in Noida

  17. Sam Battherford says:

    Amazing website, Love it. Great work done. Nice website. Love it.

  18. Sam Battherford says:

    Love it. GReat work done.
    office.com/setup

  19. Assignment help says:

    Writing an assignment for every subject might sound boring. Take the Assignment Help from genuine platforms will work the best way for getting content. Visit our platform for getting more information about the academic writing facilities from the internet.

  20. Contract management services says:

    Futuract Solution’s contract management Service focuses on delivering value through improvement in contract compliance and cycle time reduction.

  21. Portiawilliams says:

    Make the best use of your time by browsing about this awesome topic right away!

  22. Portia says:

    Internet is full of awesome data and this page is an excellent example of that.

  23. Portiawilliams says:

    Click on this article, an interesting read and a must know information for everyone.

  24. emily says:

    Canon printers have always been the most popular and widely used printing devices that include various great printing features. They are easy to set up and use for anyone with any smart device. If you want to know more about the Canon printers, you must visit its official website now via ij.start.canon.
    ij.start.canon

  25. espn.com/activate says:

    ESPN is the first company that works as a medium for bringing live sports online so that one can watch their favorite sports anytime or anywhere. To know more about the ESPN subscription plans or any other info visit espn.com/activate. If you want to know more about it feel free to get the valuable information from our website instantly.
    espn.com/activate

  26. myassignment help says:

    Myassignmenthelp is a particularly extraordinary site it helps understudies in colleges of Canada, UK, USA and Australia to finish their task and aid task related work. Anything you request, for example, research paper work or any coursework abs task assist will with being there to assist you with its answers and furthermore the work is 100% Plagiarism free and Unique.
    myassignmenthelp

  27. Data Science Course in Delhi says:

    great article..
    Data Science Course in Delhi

  28. Data Science Course says:

    Nice Post thank you very much for sharing such a useful information and will definitely saved and revisit your site and i have bookmarked to check out new things frm your post.
    Data Science Course

  29. Matlab assignment help says:

    There are certain features in which students can ask for a preview of the assignment before completion to check for any correction and quality. They will be allowed to have a chat with the expert to make any changes or add some extra points if required. Then comes the payment procedure of the assignment help services. Matlab assignment help offers a lot of payment options to facilitate the students to make easy payments. The payments are made before task submission or after getting the task done. And these are some of the quick steps to get help with Matlab assignment help.

  30. alexkim says:

    Tired of searching for document translation for passports? Now need not to worry in this regard. just hire a document translator from singaporetranslators.com and get the fast flawless translation in a short turnaround.

  31. Sam Peter says:

    Superb working and telling about metal but visit
    take my courses for me
    for online educational help.

  32. 360DIGITMGtraining says:

    I am impressed by the information that you have on this blog. It shows how well you understand this subject.
    data science training in malaysia

  33. zareen deol says:

    HBO max is compatible with any device that you might think of but there is a catch: the device

    must be connected with a high-speed internet connection, and it will be ready to rock your

    world. Setting up the HBO max with your tv and any other streaming platform is quite easy.

    Still, if you need some help regarding hbomax.com/tvsignin keep reading this blog till the end

    and you will get your answer.
    https://hbomax-comtvsignin.com

  34. Kaylee Brown says:

    Finding a reliable and useful piece of information online is not an easy task, as lots of misinformation floating all over the internet. Thanks for sharing this information. paper help online

  35. Artificial Intelligence Course says:

    Great post happy to see this. I thought this was a pretty interesting read when it comes to this topic Information. Thanks..
    Artificial Intelligence Course

  36. Jorge says:

    Love your blogs and so much inspired by dr.phills I personally follow their all blogs
    https://sky-seller.com/ted-lasso-jacket

  37. Data Science Course in Noida says:

    pretty good blog

  38. Data Science Course in Noida says:

    pretty good blog.
    Data Science Course in Noida

  39. smithwick11 says:

    Those looking for someone asking to “ Do my assignment” can reach out to our dedicated team of experts who have relevant qualifications for writing your assignments. We have extensive knowledge and use of experience in providing assistance on various subjects and topics with well-structured content and completely referenced papers.

  40. Data Science Certification in Hyderabad says:

    You have done excellent job Thanks a lot and I enjoyed your blog. Great Post.
    Data Science Certification in Hyderabad

  41. taxi says:

    You can rent car in Srinagar with us in any season, we will serve you at our best with all services including taxi service in Srinagar Kashmir.
    Kashmir car rental

  42. ccade says:

    Car rental srinagar with us and we will make sure your journeys will be one of the best journey of your life.taxi service in Srinagar

  43. Digital Marketing Course in Hyderabad says:

    Thanks Your post is so cool and this is an extraordinary moving article and If it’s not too much trouble share more like that.
    Digital Marketing Course in Hyderabad

  44. james stephens says:

    Thanks for sharing this information. ireland assignment help reviews

  45. Data Science Course says:

    Nice Post thank you very much for sharing such a useful information and will definitely saved and revisit your site and i have bookmarked to check out new things frm your post.
    Data Science Course

  46. 360DIGITMGtraining says:

    Really nice and interesting post. I was looking for this kind of information and enjoyed reading this one. Keep posting. Thanks for sharing.
    data scientist training in malaysia

  47. rickypauls pauls says:

    ​Do you sustain too hard for taking the better response of your question? I am looking around to have new logic in you post. So, it would be better to get in touch with Assignment Helper service at any cost.

  48. Royal Essay Writers says:

    Cheap essay writers UK are available for the students who have writing issues.

  49. FortuneJackets says:

    Hellow! Im Jacket Seller Custom Deign Leather Jackets Please Visit My Site Enjoy Thanks.

    Best Custom Leather Jackets

  50. Artificial Intelligence Course says:

    Great post happy to see this. I thought this was a pretty interesting read when it comes to this topic Information. Thanks..
    Artificial Intelligence Course

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *